Use Comparison Genius to compare for car insurance in Canada. We compare trusted providers so you can find cover that fits your needs and budget.
Last updated: June 2026.
| Rank | Provider | Rating | Best For | Summary | Starting Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Allstate Canada | 9.7/10 Excellent | Best Overall | Best Overall | |
| 2 | Intact Insurance | 9.2/10 Excellent | Best Coverage Network | Best Coverage Network | |
| 3 | Wawanesa Insurance | 9.0/10 Excellent | Best Value | Best Value | |
| 4 | CAA Insurance | 8.8/10 Excellent | Best for CAA Members | Best for CAA Members | |
| 5 | The Co-operators | 8.8/10 Excellent | Best Customer Service | Best Customer Service | |
| 6 | Aviva Canada | 8.6/10 Very Good | Flexible Coverage | Flexible Coverage | |
| 7 | Belair Direct | 8.6/10 Very Good | Best for Online Buyers | Best for Online Buyers | |
| 8 | Sonnet Insurance | 8.4/10 Very Good | Digital-First | Digital-First | |
| 9 | Gore Mutual | 8.4/10 Very Good | Best Claims Service | Best Claims Service | |
| 10 | TD Insurance | 8.2/10 Very Good | TD Customers | TD Customers |